According to a source close to Luke, Meghan Markle had shown interest in joining American Idol as a replacement for Katy Perry. However, Luke, along with Katy and fellow co-star Lionel Richie, was not in favor of this idea. The trio, along with host Ryan Seacrest, joined the show in 2018 for Season 16 when the renowned music competition underwent a revamp.
Katy Perry announced her departure earlier this year during an appearance on Jimmy Kimmel Live, citing her desire to focus on her pop career and release new music. Luke Bryan recently shared his thoughts on Katy's decision, mentioning that he had heard rumors about it and wasn't completely taken aback. He acknowledged that Katy might have spontaneously revealed her decision during her appearance on the show.
Reflecting on their six-year partnership, Luke emphasized the strong bond and friendship he shares with Katy, describing their time together on the show as a good run. As for his own future on American Idol, Luke explained that every year they negotiate the terms, as it's not a long-term contract. They will decide whether to return for another season as they approach the final stages of the current season.
While rumors circulate that Meghan Markle may join American Idol as a judge for Season 23, it appears clear that she would be rejected due to her perceived lack of expertise or background in music. Critics question her suitability for such a position, speculating on her underlying motives and suggesting that she may be seeking to enhance her fame through association with a high-profile television program.
The source of these allegations also suggests that Meghan's presence would be met with disdain from fellow judges, particularly Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie. The reported animosity towards Meghan stems from rumors of diva-like behavior, which could make collaboration challenging. Additionally, Lionel Richie's close relationship with King Charles adds another layer of tension, implying potential repercussions for those who align themselves unfavorably with Meghan.
As of now, ABC has not revealed who will replace Katy Perry as a judge on American Idol. However, singers like Jennifer Lopez and Taylor Swift are reportedly being considered for the role. Taylor Swift's availability for Season 23 may align with the end of her tour in late 2024, but the show's producers are not banking on securing her as a judge. Meanwhile, Jennifer Lopez has previous experience on American Idol, having appeared as a contestant in Season 10 and later returning as a judge in multiple seasons.
Former Idol winner Jordan Sparks has also expressed interest in filling Katy Perry's shoes for the upcoming season. The youngest contestant to win the competition in 2007, Jordan took to social media, tagging American Idol and tweeting her enthusiasm about joining the judges' table, stating, 'Oh hi @AmericanIdol, I'm putting my name in the hat.'"
